A brand can hardly own a smell, but it can own its name and its bottle and its place in an ad, and that explains the dupe fight you keep seeing online.
By Samuel Sayre
You may have heard that a perfume house “owns” its smell. In most places it does not. The law protects the name on the bottle and the look of the bottle, and it protects the brand from being used as someone else’s ad. The smell itself is mostly free, and that one fact explains a lot of what you may see in perfume videos.
This is an editorial explanation and not legal advice. If you sell perfume or make sponsored content, ask a lawyer where you live.
What happened in September and October 2026
Nobilis Group is a German distributor of houses such as Creed, Amouage and Maison Francis Kurkdjian [7], and its chief executive and co-owner is Udo Heuser [1, 2]. Beauty Independent reported that the company flagged creators’ videos that compared luxury perfumes with dupes to TikTok for alleged intellectual property violations [1, 2].
One suspended account belonged to Noel Deyzel, who posts as Noel Smells and had roughly 1.8 million TikTok followers. He put the suspension down to Nobilis [1, 2], and the account of the reviewer Patrón Profumo was suspended too. On 23 October 2026 Deyzel posted a video from a second account after his main one went down. Beauty Independent reported on 4 November 2026 that his main account came back roughly four days after the suspension following an appeal to TikTok, and that Patrón Profumo’s account was reinstated as well [1]. Neither report gives the date of the first suspension [1, 2].
Nobilis set out its side in its own TikTok videos. In one from 25 September 2026 it said it does not strike creators but reports all legal violations [1]. Premium Beauty News quoted Heuser’s LinkedIn post of 27 October 2026. “We only report legal violations,” he wrote, and the site reported that the company acts against what it calls unlawful comparative advertising under German and EU law [2]. The creators say they are giving honest reviews [1].
Beauty Independent also reported earlier wins for Nobilis in German courts: an injunction from a court in Düsseldorf in 2024 against the dupe seller Loris, and a 2024 ruling against the dupe seller Éclat over customer reviews on its website. That ruling became final in 2025 when Germany’s Federal Court of Justice turned down Éclat’s attempt to appeal [1]. I could not open those rulings myself, so I give them only as reported.
Look closely and you will see that the legal fight is mostly about names and ads. Heuser did argue that imitation scents “repeatedly attack the original brands” Nobilis represents, but the law he points to is about advertising [2]. Here is why.
A smell cannot be owned like a song
Copyright protects works such as a novel, a painting or a piece of music.
The leading case is about a cheese dip. In 2007 a Dutch vegetable seller created Heksenkaas, a spread of cream cheese and fresh herbs, and in 2011 the rights passed to the company Levola Hengelo. From January 2014 Smilde Foods made a rival dip called Witte Wievenkaas for a Dutch supermarket chain. Levola sued, saying the taste of its dip was a work and the rival copied it [10].
On 10 June 2015 the Gelderland District Court threw the claim out. On appeal the court in Arnhem-Leeuwarden asked the EU Court of Justice for help, and fifteen judges sat in the Grand Chamber [10]. They ruled on 13 November 2018 [3, 10] that a work must be expressed in a way that “makes it identifiable with sufficient precision and objectivity” and taste failed that test. The Court said taste rests on sensations that are subjective and variable because they depend on the person tasting. Age and habits play a part and so does the place you taste it [3].
That case was about taste and not scent. Still, a smell is judged by a nose in the same personal way, and by the reasoning of Levola I find it hard to see how a scent would pass. The London law firm Mishcon de Reya says much the same. It wrote in July 2025 that it would be difficult to argue around the judgment in favor of copyright for a fragrance [4].
The Trésor case that went the other way
One case did give a perfume copyright. It is Kecofa v Lancôme.
Kecofa was then a small Dutch firm based in Kerkrade that sold a scent called Female Treasure [8, 9]. Lancôme said its smell copied the smell of Trésor [8]. Lancôme had already tried its trademark in the word Trésor, but the courts found shoppers were unlikely to confuse the two brands [9]. On 13 July 2000 Lancôme sued Kecofa in the court at Maastricht on trademark and copyright [8].
On 8 June 2004 the appeal court in ‘s-Hertogenbosch ruled for Lancôme. It relied on a report Lancôme ordered from the French lab Breese & Majerowicz, whose expertise and findings Kecofa did not dispute, and it found the two scents too alike for Female Treasure to count as a creation of its own. On 16 June 2006 the Dutch Supreme Court rejected Kecofa’s appeal. It held that a perfume’s protection lies in its scent and not in the mix of materials that gives it off [8]. Kamiel Koelman, then an associate professor at the Vrije Universiteit in Amsterdam, noted one limit. The Supreme Court did not itself hold that Trésor was copyrightable [9].
France went the opposite way the same week. On 13 June 2006 the French Supreme Court ruled in Nejla X v Haarmann & Reimer that Dior’s Dune was not copyrightable, likening perfumers to craftsmen rather than artists [9]. On 10 December 2013 the same court again rejected copyright in a scent. The Levola judgment records that the Dutch appeal court pointed to this split between the Dutch and French top courts [10]. Mishcon de Reya calls the Dutch decision an outlier [4].
Not a patent either
A patent can protect a new process. Mishcon de Reya notes that it might cover a way to extract a fragrance or to make one last longer, but it is unlikely to cover a formula with no technical advantage. A patent also makes the recipe public, so once it runs out anyone can make the perfume [4].
So the formula is mostly protected by being kept quiet, and that has a limit. The firm says there is nothing unlawful in working out a formula from the finished product, which many dupe brands do with gas chromatography and mass spectrometry. The exception is when that work relies on confidential information [4].
Not a trademark (almost)
A trademark protects a sign that tells you who made something, and a few smells have tried.
In 1999 the smell of fresh cut grass was registered as an EU trademark for tennis balls [4]. Mishcon de Reya does not name the applicant. I could not open the 1999 decision, so I leave the name out.
Then came Ralf Sieckmann, who applied to the German patent and trademark office to register the chemical methyl cinnamate as a smell. He described it as “balsamically fruity with a slight hint of cinnamon” and gave its chemical formula along with an odor sample in a container. The office refused and the Federal Patent Court in Germany asked the EU Court of Justice. On 12 December 2002 the Court said none of it was enough, whether a formula or a written description or a sample or all three together [11].
Next came “smell of ripe strawberries” with a picture of a strawberry. Laboratoires France Parfum filed it on 26 March 1999 and the Paris company Eden SARL later took it over. An examiner at the EU trademark office refused it on 7 August 2003. On 24 May 2004 the office’s Board of Appeal agreed, and on 27 October 2005 the EU’s Court of First Instance upheld that. Eden relied on a study to show that all strawberries smell alike, but the Court read the study the other way. A sensory panel could tell five of nine crops apart by smell, so the words could point to several distinct smells [12].
The rules have since been loosened on paper. Today’s EU trademark regulation dates from 14 June 2017. A mark no longer has to be drawn or written, but it must be shown on the register in a way that gives “the clear and precise subject matter” of the protection [13]. Mishcon de Reya says no scent has been successfully registered as a UK or EU trademark since [4].
What a brand can own
Here the law is generous. A perfume house can protect its brand name and its get-up and packaging, from the label to the shape of the bottle. The tools are trademarks and design rights, and copyright and the law against passing off help too [4].
That covers the name and everything you see on the shelf. One more thing matters for the dupe fight, which is the right to stop a seller trading on the brand’s name in an ad. One case shows how that works.
The case that shows it
The case is L’Oréal v Bellure. The claimants were L’Oréal SA, Lancôme parfums et beauté and Laboratoire Garnier [14], and their marks were Trésor and Miracle plus Anaïs-Anaïs and Noa [5, 14].
On the other side were three companies. Bellure NV made the Creation Lamis and Dorall ranges, and Malaika Investments traded as Honey pot cosmetic & Perfumery Sales. Malaika and Starion International sold the copies in the United Kingdom. Creation Lamis had La Valeur (an imitation of Trésor) and Pink Wonder (an imitation of Miracle), both in bottles and boxes generally similar to the originals. Dorall’s Coffret d’Or imitated Trésor in packaging only slightly like it [14]. The sellers gave retailers comparison lists that named the luxury perfume each copy imitated [5, 14].
L’Oréal sued in the High Court in London, and the Court of Appeal asked the EU Court of Justice for guidance on 22 October 2007 [14]. The EU court decided on 18 June 2009 [5].
It ruled on both points. On the look-alike bottles it held that a seller who uses a similar look to ride on the coat-tails of a famous mark takes unfair advantage of it, even when no shopper is confused. On the lists it said EU advertising law forbids an advertiser to state that its product is “an imitation or replica” of a trademarked product, and the lists did exactly that [5]. The same rule stands in today’s EU advertising directive of 12 December 2006 [16], and Germany’s unfair competition act has it in section 6 [17].
Back in London the Court of Appeal applied the ruling on 21 May 2010. Lord Justice Jacob wrote the judgment and he did not like it. “I have come to the conclusion that the ECJ’s ruling is that the defendants are indeed muzzled,” he wrote. He said he followed it “with regret” and that left to himself he would let traders make honest statements about lawful products [15].
Note who the case was about. It was about companies marketing their own copies [5]. Whether a creator’s video is advertising or an honest review is the open question, and Premium Beauty News described the dispute in just those terms [2].
The United States takes a different line
The American rule starts from the other end. On 13 August 1979 the Federal Trade Commission published a policy statement on comparative advertising that says the Commission “encourages the naming of, or reference to” competitors. It asks for clarity and for disclosure where needed to avoid deceiving people, and it calls truthful comparative advertising “a source of important information to consumers” [6].
Beauty Independent reported that independent reviews in the US generally enjoy strong legal protection, while sponsored promotions and affiliate links can draw closer scrutiny [1].
Fake, dupe and “inspired by”
These are not the same thing. A fake copies the brand’s name and packaging to pass as the real bottle, while a dupe sets out to smell like a famous perfume without pretending to be it [4]. I explain the difference in my 60-second checklist. My guide to spotting a counterfeit perfume goes further, and my page on genuine or fake has ten signs to check.
What this means for you
None of these cases is about what you smell at home. You can wear a perfume because it reminds you of another and you can say so to a friend.
A seller in the EU is in a different spot. Under Bellure it may not advertise its perfume as an imitation of a trademarked one [5]. If a video never says the famous name out loud, now you know one possible reason.
Wear what you love, because the law has not changed that. My old post on choosing a fragrance with thought is still up.
How I name originals here
On this site I describe perfumes and compare them. I don’t sell perfume, and my Smells Like pages work that way. The rules that decide what goes into a bottle are a separate matter that my page on perfume regulation covers.
To browse every entry, start at the Library Index.
- Erica La Sala, “Beauty’s Dupe Battle Moves To TikTok As Creed Distributor Faces Backlash Over Creator Suspensions,” Beauty Independent, 4 November 2026 (updated 5 November). beautyindependent.com
- Vincent Gallon, “Noel Deyzel’s account suspension reignites debate over fragrance dupes,” Premium Beauty News, 27 October 2026. premiumbeautynews.com
- Court of Justice of the European Union, Press Release No 171/18, “The taste of a food product is not eligible for copyright protection,” judgment in Case C-310/17 Levola Hengelo BV v Smilde Foods BV, 13 November 2018. curia.europa.eu
- Mishcon de Reya (law firm), “Perfume: IP protection and the fight against dupes,” 22 July 2025. mishcon.com
- Court of Justice of the European Communities, Press Release No 54/09, judgment in Case C-487/07 L’Oréal and Others v Bellure NV and Others, 18 June 2009. curia.europa.eu
- US Federal Trade Commission, “In regard to comparative advertising,” 16 CFR 14.15 (44 FR 47328, 13 August 1979), Electronic Code of Federal Regulations. ecfr.gov (text read through the eCFR API: ecfr.gov)
- Nobilis Group, “Brands.” nobilis-group.com
- Hoge Raad der Nederlanden (Dutch Supreme Court), Kecofa v Lancôme, judgment of 16 June 2006, ECLI:NL:HR:2006:AU8940. uitspraken.rechtspraak.nl (full text read through the court’s open data service: data.rechtspraak.nl)
- Kamiel Koelman, “Copyright in the Courts: Perfume as Artistic Expression?,” WIPO Magazine, 5 September 2006. wipo.int
- Court of Justice of the European Union (Grand Chamber), judgment of 13 November 2018, Case C-310/17 Levola Hengelo BV v Smilde Foods BV, EUR-Lex, paragraph 24 (citing the French ruling of 10 December 2013: Cour de cassation, chambre commerciale (Cass. com.), pourvoi 11-19.872, ECLI:FR:CCASS:2013:CO01205). eur-lex.europa.eu
- Court of Justice of the European Communities, judgment of 12 December 2002, Case C-273/00 Ralf Sieckmann, EUR-Lex. eur-lex.europa.eu
- Court of First Instance of the European Communities (Third Chamber), judgment of 27 October 2005, Case T-305/04 Eden SARL v OHIM (smell of ripe strawberries), EUR-Lex. eur-lex.europa.eu
- Regulation (EU) 2017/1001 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 14 June 2017 on the European Union trade mark, Article 4 and recital 10, EUR-Lex. eur-lex.europa.eu
- Court of Justice of the European Communities (First Chamber), judgment of 18 June 2009, Case C-487/07 L’Oréal SA and Others v Bellure NV and Others, EUR-Lex. eur-lex.europa.eu
- Court of Appeal of England and Wales, L’Oréal SA and Others v Bellure NV and Others [2010] EWCA Civ 535, judgment of 21 May 2010, The National Archives Find Case Law. caselaw.nationalarchives.gov.uk
- Directive 2006/114/EC of the European Parliament and of the Council of 12 December 2006 concerning misleading and comparative advertising, Article 4(g), EUR-Lex. eur-lex.europa.eu
- Gesetz gegen den unlauteren Wettbewerb (German Act against Unfair Competition), section 6(2) no. 6, Gesetze im Internet (German Federal Ministry of Justice). gesetze-im-internet.de