dsm-firmenich says reformulation helped its consumer fragrance sales grow, so here is what reformulation is, why it happens and how to tell if your perfume has changed.
By Samuel Sayre
On 4 November dsm-firmenich published its third-quarter trading update. The company creates fragrance for other companies’ brands [3]. Its Perfumery and Beauty unit grew 8% like for like, to €1.02 billion in sales [1, 2].
One line caught my eye. The company wrote that Consumer Fragrances “delivered another quarter of double-digit LFL growth owing to innovation and reformulations” [1, 2].
That is an honest sentence. It is also a useful one. It shows that rewriting a formula is paid work for a fragrance supplier. Rewriting formulas is part of how the industry earns money.
First, what “Consumer Fragrances” means
This matters, so I want to be precise. At dsm-firmenich “Consumer Fragrances” is not fine perfume. It is the scent inside everyday products. The company’s own page lists detergents and fabric softeners. It also lists shampoo, body wash, deodorant and air care [3].
Fine perfume sits in a separate line called Fine Fragrances. That line grew at a high single-digit rate in the quarter [1, 2]. The update does not credit reformulation for that growth [1].
So this sentence is about your laundry before it is about your perfume. The same forces act on both, though. The rest of this post explains them.
What reformulation is
A perfume is a formula. It is a list of materials and amounts written by a perfumer. Reformulation means that list changes while the name on the bottle stays the same.
Sometimes the change is tiny. One supplier’s version of a material is swapped for another’s. Sometimes it is large. A whole base is rebuilt because one key material is no longer allowed. In my experience a perfect match is rare. Materials do not behave alike on skin, even when they smell alike on a strip.
Why it happens
Perfumers name four main reasons. They are regulation, shortages, cost and plain adaptation [4, 5].
Industry safety rules. The International Fragrance Association (IFRA) writes the IFRA Standards. They ban some materials and cap others [6, 8]. IFRA says its members must follow them [6]. IFRA updates them in numbered amendments. Each sets deadlines for new and existing fragrances [6, 8]. Every deadline in the 51st Amendment has now passed. The last one fell on 30 October 2025 [7, 8]. IFRA expects to notify the 52nd in January 2027 [7, 9]. Its final draft has 48 new restriction Standards [7, 9]. I expect that to bring another wave of rewrites.
EU law. In 2023 the EU added 56 fragrance allergens to its labeling rules [10, 11]. Since 31 July 2026 a new product must name them on the label. Older stock can be sold until 31 July 2028 [10, 12]. Labeling alone does not force a new formula. Some brands will still choose to cut an allergen rather than print it.
The EU also bans some materials outright. Atranol and chloroatranol are natural parts of oakmoss and treemoss extracts [13, 14]. The EU banned both in cosmetics. New products had to comply from 23 August 2019. Shops had to stop selling non-compliant stock from 23 August 2021 [13, 14]. That is a big reason modern chypres smell different. See my entry on oakmoss.
Lilial was a common material for lily of the valley [15, 19]. The EU banned it from 1 March 2022 over reproductive toxicity [16, 17]. Many white florals had to be rebuilt. See my entry on lily of the valley.
Shortages. Natural crops fail. Factories stop making old synthetics. Suzy Le Helley, a fine fragrance perfumer at Symrise, named both as causes of reformulation [4]. Perfumer Nathalie Rouquet lists raw material shortages too [5].
Cost. Perfumers also name cost [5]. Tammy Frazer, the perfumer behind Frazer Parfum, has written that prices can climb so far that a change becomes unavoidable [18]. Cost is the reason brands discuss least. I cannot prove that any single change was made for cost. I can say it is on every perfumer’s list.
What it means for the bottle you own
The bottle in your hand will not change. A formula change only affects bottles made after it.
A new bottle with the same name may not be the same perfume. The brand is not required to tell you. In my experience most do not.
A different smell is not always a new formula. Natural materials vary from harvest to harvest. Your own nose and skin change over time. The top of a bottle you have used for a year has aged in the air.
How to tell
- Read the box. Compare the ingredient list on an old box with a new one. A material that vanished or appeared is a strong clue. Since July 2026 a new box may also show a much longer allergen list [10, 12]. That means new labeling, and on its own it does not prove a new formula.
- Read the batch code. Most boxes carry a printed or stamped code. It ties the bottle to a production run. Note it when you buy a scent you love.
- Smell side by side. Spray each on a separate paper strip. Wait an hour, then smell again. Most changes show in the base, not the opening.
- Ask the brand. Write to customer service and name the batch code. Ask whether the formula has changed since a given year. A clear answer is worth keeping.
My Library entry on what reformulation means goes deeper into each of these steps.
If you want help finding the current version of a scent you loved, or a modern scent in the same family, tell me about you and your favorite scents. For the materials behind the rules, start at the Library Index.
- dsm-firmenich, “dsm-firmenich reports Q3 2026 trading update,” press release (PDF), 4 November 2026, page 2. our-company.dsm-firmenich.com (web version: our-company.dsm-firmenich.com)
- Investing.com, “dsm-firmenich raises 2026 sales outlook after volume-led Q3 growth,” 4 November 2026. za.investing.com
- dsm-firmenich, “Consumer Brands: Success through consumer understanding.” dsm-firmenich.com
- Premium Beauty News, “Olfactory reformulation, a delicate exercise” (interview with Suzy Le Helley of Symrise), 9 June 2020. premiumbeautynews.com
- Cosmetics Business, “Fragrance reformulation is on the rise: this perfumer explains why it’s needed” (Nathalie Rouquet), 9 June 2026. cosmeticsbusiness.com
- IFRA (industry body), “IFRA Standards.” ifrafragrance.org
- IFRA (industry body), “IFRA publishes End of Consultation Letter for the 52nd Amendment to the IFRA Standards,” 1 September 2026, updated 4 November 2026. ifrafragrance.org
- UL Solutions, “IFRA Notifies 51st Amendment to IFRA Standards,” 10 July 2023. ul.com
- Maven Regulatory Solutions, “IFRA 52nd Amendment: 2026 fragrance compliance guide,” 22 October 2026. mavenrs.com
- European Commission, “Fragrance allergens labelling.” single-market-economy.ec.europa.eu
- Exponent, “EU Cosmetic Regulation Adds 56 New Fragrance Allergens,” 6 September 2023. exponent.com
- Health Products Regulatory Authority (Ireland), “Labelling of cosmetic fragrance allergens.” hpra.ie
- Commission Regulation (EU) 2017/1410 of 2 August 2017, recital 4 and Article 2 (EU text as held by legislation.gov.uk). legislation.gov.uk and legislation.gov.uk
- SGS SafeGuardS 126/17, “Commission Finally Bans Three Fragrance Allergens,” 11 August 2017 (via MarketScreener). ca.marketscreener.com
- Consumer NZ, “Lilial is now banned in cosmetics. So why is it still everywhere?” consumer.org.nz
- Obelis, “Lilial and Zinc Pyrithione banned in the EU,” 23 March 2022. obelis.net
- CosLaw.eu, “Omnibus IV: new ingredients banned in cosmetics,” 5 November 2021. coslaw.eu
- Mail & Guardian, “Making scents: Raw deals can ruin a perfumer” (Tammy Frazer), 8 August 2014. mg.co.za
- Cosmetics Business, “Lilial ingredient ban comes into force in Great Britain” (Julia Wray), 16 December 2022. cosmeticsbusiness.com
- Nez, “Madagascar, a unique testing ground for natural ingredients” (Suzy Le Helley, Symrise). mag.bynez.com
- Wanted, “Unique signatures: perfumer Tammy Frazer,” 18 August 2017. wantedonline.co.za