Jean Carles

LIBRARY · PERFUMERS
Jean Carles

Lost his sense of smell late in life and kept composing from memory. Invented the way perfumery is taught.

DATES
1892 — 1966
NATIONALITY
French
HOUSE
Roure Bertrand Dupont
DEFINING WORK
Ma Griffe, 1946
QUICK ANSWER

Who was Jean Carles?

Jean Carles was a perfumer at Roure Bertrand Dupont in Grasse. He composed Dana Tabu in 1932 and Carven Ma Griffe in 1946. He founded the first formal perfumery school, the ancestor of the Givaudan Perfumery School. His method for teaching composition shaped how perfumery is taught. He lost his sense of smell mid-career and kept composing from memory.

01 — OVERVIEW

Overview

Jean Carles was a perfumer at Roure Bertrand Dupont in Grasse, the composer of Carven Ma Griffe (1946) and Dana Tabu (1932), and the founder of the first formal perfumery school — the Roure school, direct ancestor of the Givaudan Perfumery School.

His influence on the industry is primarily pedagogical. The method he devised for teaching composition — systematic study of raw materials, then binary and ternary accords, then the pyramid — is still substantially how perfumers are trained, and almost every working perfumer is a descendant of it at some remove.

02 — TRAINING AND BACKGROUND

Training and background

He trained in Grasse and spent his career in the composition houses rather than in a fine-fragrance brand, which is the important structural fact about him: he was a supplier’s perfumer, working to briefs from client companies, at a time when that model was becoming the industry norm.

At Roure he built the technical function into a teaching institution. The school opened in 1946 and its curriculum was his — a syllabus of several hundred materials to be learned by memory and by pairwise comparison before any composition was attempted.

03 — SIGNATURE STYLE

Signature style

Carles’s own compositions are constructed rather than intuited, and the difference from Jacques Guerlain is instructive. Ma Griffe is a green chypre of visible architecture: galbanum and citrus over jasmine and ylang-ylang over oakmoss, vetiver and labdanum, with each stage doing an identifiable job.

Tabu is the other pole — a heavy animalic oriental, one of the strongest patchouli-and-civet compositions of the period.

04 — MATERIALS AND TECHNIQUE

Materials and technique

The method is the contribution. Carles taught composition as a three-stage pyramid — top, heart, base — with the base built first and the top last, and with accords developed in isolation before assembly. He set out the approach in a series of articles later collected as A Method of Creation in Perfumery, which remains in circulation.

The biographical fact usually attached to him is that he became anosmic in later life and continued to compose by structure and memory, working from formulae and from his knowledge of how materials behave rather than from smell. His son Marcel Carles said the loss came toward the end of Jean’s life, and how complete it was is not documented. Either way it is a fair emblem of a perfumer whose method was explicitly intellectual.

05 — KEY WORKS

Key works

Dana Tabu, 1932 — heavy animalic oriental; patchouli, civet and resins.
Carven Ma Griffe, 1946 — the green chypre and his most studied composition.
Dana Canoe, 1935 — a fougère-adjacent aromatic, and a large commercial success.
Dana 20 Carats, 1933 — one of several Dana commissions of the period.
The Roure school, 1946 — the pedagogical work, and arguably the more consequential output.
06 — HOUSES AND COLLABORATIONS

Houses and collaborations

He worked at Roure Bertrand Dupont, one of the great Grasse composition houses, which passed through a series of ownerships and is now part of Givaudan. His clients were brands — Dana, Carven, Revillon — rather than his employers. Credit is split: Bois de Jasmin names him with Paul Vacher as co-author of Christian Dior’s Miss Dior (1947). Now Smell This says it was made by Vacher or Carles or possibly both.

His pupils and their pupils constitute much of the profession. Edmond Roudnitska worked at Roure in the same period, though the two men’s approaches were markedly different and their relationship was not close. The Givaudan school’s alumni include a substantial share of the perfumers working today.

His son Marcel Carles was also a perfumer.

07 — INFLUENCE

Influence

The pyramid is Carles’s legacy and it is everywhere: in training, in the way fragrances are described commercially, and in the note lists printed on every box. It is also a simplification, and a fair criticism of his influence is that the industry took a teaching device and turned it into a description of how perfumes actually work, which they largely do not.

The school model, by contrast, has been vindicated. Systematic materials training before composition is still how his school works: Givaudan says its apprentices memorize more than 500 ingredients through an updated form of his method.

08 — HISTORICAL ASSESSMENT

Historical assessment

Carles is respected rather than romanticized, and his compositions are less discussed than his method. Ma Griffe and Tabu both survive in reformulated versions that have lost a good deal — the oakmoss in the first and the animalics in the second are the casualties.

The honest assessment is that he was a very good perfumer and an extraordinary teacher, and that the industry’s ability to reproduce competence across generations is largely his doing. The anosmia story, whatever its accuracy, has probably done more for his reputation than any of his perfumes.

09 — SOURCES

Sources

[111] Osmothèque, Versailles — conservatory of historical fragrance formulae and reconstructions.
[37] Carles, J. “A Method of Creation in Perfumery,” Soap, Perfumery and Cosmetics, 1961–62.
[10] Edwards, M. Perfume Legends / Fragrances of the World, various editions.
[30] Turin, L. & Sanchez, T. Perfumes: The Guide, 2008.
[13] Ellena, J.-C. Perfume: The Alchemy of Scent, 2011.

RELATED ENTRIES

SOURCES

Osmothèque, Versailles; Michael Edwards, Perfume Legends; Fragrance Foundation.

From the Library

New entries, in your inbox

I keep adding to the Library. Leave your email and I will send you what is new. You can leave any time.