Clove

LIBRARY · ORIENTAL
Clove

An unopened flower bud that produced one of perfumery’s most used molecules — and one of its most restricted.

BOTANICAL NAME
Syzygium aromaticum
CAS
8000-34-8 (bud oil)
POSITION
Top · heart
STATUS
IFRA restricted
QUICK ANSWER

What does clove smell like in perfume?

Clove smells hot and dry, sweet and penetrating, with a phenolic-medicinal core. Its bite connects it to dentistry for most people. It is the dried unopened flower bud of a tree native to the Maluku Islands. Eugenol usually makes up seventy to eighty-five percent of the bud oil. That one molecule is among the most used and most restricted in perfumery.

01 — DEFINITION

Definition

Clove is the dried unopened flower bud of Syzygium aromaticum, an evergreen tree of the myrtle family native to the Maluku Islands. The perfumery materials are the steam-distilled oils of the bud, leaf and stem, and the bud absolute; all are dominated by eugenol, which in bud oil typically runs between seventy and eighty-five percent.

Because a single molecule accounts for so much of the smell, clove is one of the few naturals whose character can be approached with an isolate. That is also why it is regulated as it is: the restriction applies to eugenol and isoeugenol, and the natural oil is limited by arithmetic on its constituents rather than as a material in its own right.

02 — OLFACTORY CHARACTER

Olfactory character

Hot, dry, sweet and penetrating, with a phenolic-medicinal core and a faint fruity-woody depth underneath. It has genuine bite — the trigeminal, almost anesthetic quality that connects it to dentistry in most people’s associations.

The three oils differ. Bud oil is the finest: rounder, sweeter, more floral, and the one used in fine fragrance. Leaf oil is harsher, more phenolic and cheaper, and is mostly a feedstock for eugenol isolation. Stem oil sits between them. Clove absolute is softer and more balsamic than any of the distillates and holds the fruity facet best.

03 — HISTORICAL DEVELOPMENT

Historical development

Clove was among the most valuable commodities of the medieval and early-modern spice trade, and the Dutch monopoly over Maluku production in the seventeenth and eighteenth centuries was enforced by destroying trees outside the islands. Its scenting use — pomanders, clove-studded oranges, scented gloves — long predates compounded perfumery.

Its perfumery importance is bound to the carnation. The flower’s smell is largely eugenol, and the classical carnation accord — eugenol with rose and ylang — made clove materials structural to a whole genre of early twentieth-century floral perfumery, of which Caron Bellodgia (1927) is the reference.

That genre is now effectively unbuildable at its original strength. Eugenol and isoeugenol were identified as significant contact allergens, and successive IFRA amendments and EU labeling rules have reduced permitted levels substantially — isoeugenol very sharply. Modern carnations are reconstructed at a fraction of the historical dose, or with methyl-substituted analogs, and they do not smell the same.

04 — MATERIALS

Materials

NATURAL

Clove bud oil (CAS 8000-34-8), steam-distilled from dried buds, 70–85% eugenol, the fine-fragrance grade; clove leaf oil (CAS 8015-97-2), harsher and higher in eugenol, largely an isolation feedstock; clove stem oil (CAS 8015-98-3); clove bud absolute, softer and more balsamic; clove CO2 extract, closest to the ground spice.

SYNTHETIC

Eugenol (CAS 97-53-0) is available both as an isolate from clove leaf oil and synthetically, and is one of the highest-volume fragrance materials in existence. Isoeugenol is sweeter and more floral, and more tightly restricted. The compliant workarounds are methyl eugenol analogs and materials such as eugenyl acetate and isoeugenyl acetate, which shift the character toward the floral-balsamic and away from the medicinal.

In most modern formulae the clove effect is delivered by isolate plus supporting materials, with a small dose of bud oil or absolute for naturalness.

05 — GRADING AND QUALITY

Grading and quality

Plant part first: bud, leaf and stem oils are three different articles at three different prices, and misdescription is common. Bud oil should be specified explicitly, with eugenol content stated.

Then origin and eugenol assay. Indonesian and Madagascan material dominate; Madagascan bud oil is generally regarded as the cleaner. Clove oils darken and thicken on storage through eugenol oxidation, so a distillation date and evidence of proper storage matter more here than for most spice oils. Adulteration with clove leaf oil or added eugenol is the standard practice to watch for — and is detectable, since bud oil’s value lies in its minor constituents rather than its eugenol percentage.

06 — SOURCING AND SUSTAINABILITY

Sourcing and sustainability

Indonesia produces the large majority of the world clove crop, followed by Madagascar and Tanzania. The dominant end use is not food or fragrance but kretek, the clove cigarettes that consume most Indonesian production domestically — which means the fragrance industry is a small buyer in a market whose price it does not influence.

Production is overwhelmingly smallholder, and the trees are long-lived and slow to come into bearing, so supply responds to price with a lag of years rather than seasons. Cyclone exposure in Madagascar and disease pressure in Indonesia are the recurring shocks.

Because eugenol can be isolated from clove leaf — a by-product of pruning — and is also produced synthetically, the fragrance industry’s exposure to clove crop failure is limited. The material at risk is fine bud oil and absolute, not the eugenol effect.

07 — SAFETY AND REGULATION

Safety and regulation

How these limits are set, and what changes in the 52nd Amendment expected in January 2027, is explained in IFRA Standards and amendments. The full list of capped and banned materials is on Restricted and banned materials.

Clove is the wedge’s clearest example of a material constrained by a single well-characterised allergen, and the constraint is on the molecule rather than the oil.

Eugenol — IFRA-restricted by finished-product concentration; EU declarable allergen above 0.001% in leave-on products.
Isoeugenol — substantially more restricted than eugenol under IFRA; EU declarable allergen. The tighter of the two limits usually governs a formula.
Clove bud, leaf and stem oils — not restricted as oils; limited in practice by the eugenol and isoeugenol they contribute to the total.
Sensitization — eugenol is a recognized cause of contact dermatitis and appears on standard patch-test series; the dental association is not coincidental.
Formulation note — clove oils discolor on oxidation and can darken a pale base; antioxidant protection and dated stock are standard practice.

Check the current amendment before formulating. Eugenol limits have moved more than once, and a formula compliant under an earlier amendment may not be under the present one.

08 — COMMON ACCORDS

Common accords

Carnation — eugenol with rose and ylang — the accord clove is definitional to.
Oriental spice — with cinnamon, vanilla and labdanum, the classical warm base.
Leather — with birch tar and isobutyl quinoline, using the phenolic side.
Chai — with cardamom, ginger and cinnamon over milk and sandalwood.
Pomander — with mandarin and orange — the oldest clove accord in Western use.
Spicy floral trace — a few tenths of a percent under jasmine or tuberose to add heat and lift.
09 — FRAGRANCE FAMILIES

Fragrance families

Clove is definitional to the carnation and to the spicy-oriental, and structural in the classical floral-oriental. Its phenolic character makes it useful in leather and in incense compositions, and trace doses appear across the floral families. Its historical footprint is much larger than its current one, and the difference is entirely regulatory.

10 — EXAMPLES

Examples

Caron Bellodgia (1927) is the reference carnation and the standard illustration of what eugenol restriction cost. Guerlain L’Heure Bleue (1912) and Shalimar (1925) use clove as part of their spice-balsamic structure.

Comme des Garçons Series 3 Incense: Kyoto and Serge Lutens Serge Noire are the usual modern citations for clove used prominently within current limits. As with the mossy wedge, note lists on reissued classics describe the intent rather than the present formula.

11 — HISTORICAL TERMINOLOGY

Historical terminology

The English name comes via French clou, nail, for the bud’s shape; girofle and clou de girofle are the French trade names, and eugénol takes its name from Eugenia, the older genus. Botanical synonyms include Eugenia caryophyllata, still seen on documentation. “Clove oil” without a plant part is ambiguous; “oil of cloves” in older pharmacopeias generally means bud oil.

13 — SOURCES

Sources

[67] IFRA Standards Library (Amendment 51). ifrafragrance.org
[62] Regulation (EC) 1223/2009, annex III — eugenol and isoeugenol labelling.
[79] SCCS opinions on eugenol and isoeugenol as fragrance sensitisers.
[2] Arctander, S. Perfume and Flavor Materials of Natural Origin, 1960.
[117] ScenTree — material monographs: origin, extraction and regulatory notes. scentree.co

Not sure what suits you? Find your match with the Scent Match quiz.

From the Library

New entries, in your inbox

I keep adding to the Library. Leave your email and I will send you what is new. You can leave any time.